Collected 94 rental agreements from students who were willing to share the number, anonymised, around Herzliya and north Tel Aviv.
The listing price and the signed price differ by a median of 3.4% — much less than I expected. Almost nobody negotiates.
The interesting spread is elsewhere. For the same number of rooms in the same neighbourhood, a flat found through a group chat costs about 9% less than one found through an agency, and the gap is almost exactly the agency fee.
Ninety-four is a small sample of people willing to tell me what they pay, which is its own bias. I would not quote any of these numbers as a fact about the market.