The marketplace worked. The pricing destroyed it.
128 books listed, 19 sold, and a mistake I could have avoided by asking one question.
Textbooks here cost between 200 and 600 shekels. Everyone sells them at the end of term on WhatsApp, badly. I built a listing site for it.
The build went fine. Listings, photos, a search that works, messages between buyer and seller. Up in two weeks.
The numbers
128 books listed in the first month. 19 sold. That is a 15% conversion from listing to sale, and I have no idea whether that is good, because I never asked what the WhatsApp groups convert at.
Where it broke
I let sellers set their own price, with no reference. So the same edition of the same statistics book was listed at 90, at 180, and at 310. Buyers saw three prices, concluded that nobody knew what the book was worth, and went back to the group chat where at least they could haggle with a human.
The fix was not a feature. It was showing the last three prices that edition actually sold for, right under the price box. Sellers started anchoring to it immediately. The spread on that statistics book is now 110 to 160.
What I would tell myself in September
Ask what the thing you are replacing converts at, before you build. I still cannot tell you whether 15% was a disaster or a success, and that is my own fault.